Why Every YouTuber Needs an Email List (And How to Build One)
Riffit Team
Content Team
Why Every YouTuber Needs an Email List (And How to Build One)
You've spent months—maybe years—building your YouTube channel. You have thousands of subscribers, consistent views, maybe even sponsorship deals.
But here's the uncomfortable truth: You don't own your audience.
YouTube does.
And one algorithm change could cut your reach by 50% overnight. It's happened before, and it will happen again.
The Algorithm Can Change Tomorrow
Real Stories From Real Creators
Case Study 1: Education Channel
- Had 150K subscribers
- Averaged 50K views per video
- January 2022: YouTube changed algorithm priorities
- Views dropped to 8K per video overnight
- Result: Lost 84% of reach in one update
Case Study 2: Tech Review Channel
- Had 500K subscribers
- Made $15K/month from AdSense
- Got demonetized for "reused content" (false flag)
- Took 6 months to get reinstated
- Result: Lost $90K in revenue during appeals
Case Study 3: Gaming Channel
- Had 75K subscribers
- One video flagged incorrectly
- Entire channel got strike
- Second strike 2 weeks later
- Result: Channel deleted, years of work gone
What They All Had in Common
None of them had email lists.
They couldn't reach their audience when YouTube cut them off. They had no way to:
- Announce new content
- Share important updates
- Promote products or services
- Ask for support during the crisis
Their businesses depended entirely on a platform they didn't control.
Why Email is Different
You Own Your List
When you have someone's email address:
- You can reach them any time
- No algorithm decides if they see your message
- No platform can take your list away
- You control the relationship
The Numbers Don't Lie
| Metric | YouTube | Email | |--------|---------|-------| | Average Reach | 5-10% of subscribers | 20-30% of subscribers | | Conversion Rate | 1-2% | 3-5% | | Control | YouTube controls | You control | | Cost | Free (but risky) | $20-50/month (but safe) | | Longevity | Platform-dependent | Forever yours |
Email Drives More Revenue
Data from 1,000+ creators shows:
- Email converts 3x better than YouTube community posts
- Email subscribers spend 4x more on products/courses
- Email click-through rates are 5x higher than social media
Why? Because email is:
- More personal
- Less distracting
- Action-oriented
- In their inbox (where buying happens)
But I Have YouTube Subscribers—Isn't That Enough?
No. Here's why:
1. YouTube Subscribers Don't See Everything
YouTube's algorithm only shows your videos to a small percentage of your subscribers.
Reality:
- You have 10,000 subscribers
- Only 500-1,000 actually see your new video in their feed
- That's 5-10% reach
With email:
- You have 2,000 email subscribers
- 600 open your email (30% open rate)
- That's 30% reach—and these people actually opted in
2. YouTube Notifications are Unreliable
"Just tell people to click the notification bell!"
Problems:
- Most people don't
- YouTube limits notifications (not every video triggers one)
- People turn off notifications because they get too many
- Notifications don't work if they're not online
Email always arrives.
3. You Can't Segment YouTube Subscribers
On YouTube, everyone sees the same content.
With email, you can:
- Send beginners different content than advanced users
- Promote products only to engaged subscribers
- Share exclusive content with superfans
- Test different approaches with different segments
Segmentation = Higher conversions
How to Build Your Email List From YouTube
Strategy 1: End-of-Video CTA
What to do:
- At the end of every video, mention your newsletter
- Explain what they get (exclusive content, early access, etc.)
- Direct them to the signup link
Script example:
"If you want the written version of this tutorial with all the code snippets, I send that to my newsletter subscribers every week. Link is in the description."
Why it works:
- People who watched to the end are highly engaged
- You're offering additional value, not just asking for email
- Natural fit in your content flow
Results: 1-3% of viewers sign up (on 10K views = 100-300 emails)
Strategy 2: Pinned Comment
What to do:
- Pin a comment on every video
- Offer something specific and valuable
- Include direct link to signup
Example:
"📧 Want this video as a step-by-step checklist? I send every tutorial in written format to my email list. Join 5,000+ creators: [link]"
Why it works:
- People read pinned comments
- Offering specific value (checklist) is compelling
- Social proof (5,000+ creators) builds trust
Results: 0.5-1% additional signups
Strategy 3: Lead Magnet in Description
What to do:
- Create a free resource related to video
- First line of description: Link to get it
- Require email to access
Lead magnet ideas:
- Checklist version of video
- Template or tool mentioned in video
- Bonus section not in video
- Resource list from video
- PDF guide expanding on topic
Example:
"📥 Download the complete SEO checklist from this video (free): [link]"
Why it works:
- You're giving them something they already want
- They've just watched your video, trust is high
- Email is the natural "payment" for free resource
Results: 3-5% of viewers opt in
Strategy 4: Video-to-Newsletter Automation
What to do:
- Convert every video to a newsletter
- Send it to your email list
- Give email subscribers value YouTube viewers don't get
How it works:
- Publish YouTube video
- Convert video to written newsletter (using Riffit)
- Send to email list with exclusive additions
- Include CTA to watch full video
Why it works:
- Repurposes content you already created
- Reaches people who prefer reading
- Keeps email list warm with consistent value
- Drives traffic back to YouTube (helps algorithm)
Example workflow:
- Monday: Publish YouTube video
- Tuesday: Send newsletter version with:
- Written summary of video
- Bonus tips not in video
- Link to watch full video
- Call-to-action (product/course/next video)
Results: Higher engagement, better retention, more revenue
Strategy 5: Channel Trailer Pitch
What to do:
- In your channel trailer (for non-subscribers)
- Prominently mention your newsletter
- Show what they get
Script example:
"I publish weekly tutorials on [topic]. I also send every tutorial as a written guide to my newsletter—completely free. Link in description if you want both."
Why it works:
- New visitors see this first
- Gives them two ways to follow (YouTube + Email)
- Some people prefer email
Results: Converts 2-4% of new visitors
What to Send Your Email List
Don't just duplicate YouTube content. Give them more.
Weekly Newsletter Ideas:
-
Video Summary + Bonus
- Main points from this week's video
- 2-3 bonus tips not in video
- Resources and tools mentioned
- Link to watch full video
-
Behind the Scenes
- How you made this week's video
- What didn't make the cut
- Lessons learned
- Upcoming content sneak peek
-
Exclusive Content
- Deep dives too long for YouTube
- Controversial opinions
- Personal updates
- Early access to new videos
-
Curated Resources
- Best articles/tools you found this week
- Other creators you recommend
- Trending topics in your niche
Email Frequency:
Best practices:
- Weekly: Most common and effective
- Twice/week: If you have enough content
- Monthly: Minimum to stay relevant
- Daily: Only if you're a news channel
Rule: Consistency beats frequency. Weekly every Tuesday is better than random sporadic emails.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake #1: No Clear Value Proposition
Bad: "Subscribe to my newsletter!"
Good: "Get every tutorial as a step-by-step written guide delivered to your inbox every Tuesday."
Why: People need to know what they're getting and when.
Mistake #2: Asking Too Early
Bad: Asking for email in first 30 seconds of video
Good: Mentioning newsletter after providing value
Why: Earn trust first, then ask.
Mistake #3: Forgetting to Email Them
Bad: Building a list and never sending emails
Good: Consistent weekly emails with value
Why: "The money is in the list" only if you actually use it.
Mistake #4: Only Promotional Emails
Bad: Every email is trying to sell something
Good: 80% value, 20% promotion
Why: People unsubscribe from sales pitches, not from valuable content.
Tools You'll Need
Email Platform (Choose One):
- ConvertKit - Best for creators ($29/month, 1K subscribers)
- Mailchimp - Free up to 500 subscribers
- Beehiiv - Best for newsletter-focused creators (free tier available)
- Klaviyo - Best for e-commerce ($20/month, 500 contacts)
Content Conversion:
- Riffit - Convert YouTube videos to newsletters automatically (free for 3/month)
- Manual - Download transcript, rewrite yourself (free, takes 2-3 hours)
Lead Magnet Creation:
- Canva - For PDF checklists and guides (free)
- Google Docs - For simple text-based resources (free)
- Notion - For interactive resources (free)
Timeline: Your First 90 Days
Month 1: Setup
- Week 1: Choose email platform, set up account
- Week 2: Create lead magnet (checklist/guide/template)
- Week 3: Add signup links to all existing videos
- Week 4: Send first newsletter to initial subscribers
Goal: 50-100 subscribers
Month 2: Grow
- Week 1: Add CTA to end of every new video
- Week 2: Create 2nd lead magnet
- Week 3: Pin comments on all new videos
- Week 4: Optimize welcome email sequence
Goal: 200-300 total subscribers
Month 3: Scale
- Week 1: Start weekly newsletter rhythm
- Week 2: Test different CTAs and offers
- Week 3: Promote email list on social media
- Week 4: Analyze what's working, double down
Goal: 500+ subscribers
Success Metrics
Track these numbers weekly:
| Metric | Good | Great | |--------|------|-------| | Signup rate (% of viewers) | 1-2% | 3-5% | | Email open rate | 20-30% | 35-45% | | Click-through rate | 2-5% | 5-10% | | Unsubscribe rate | <0.5% | <0.2% | | List growth (week-over-week) | 5-10% | 15-25% |
Real Creator Results
Case Study: Tech Tutorial Channel
Before email list:
- 50K YouTube subscribers
- 15K avg views per video
- $2K/month revenue
After building email list (6 months):
- 3,500 email subscribers
- Started selling course through email
- Revenue jumped to $8K/month
Key insight: "Email subscribers convert 10x better than YouTube viewers. When I launch a course, 5% of my email list buys vs. 0.5% of YouTube viewers."
Conclusion
Building an email list isn't optional anymore—it's essential for long-term success as a creator.
You need an email list because:
- You don't own your YouTube audience (YouTube does)
- Algorithms change without warning
- Email converts 3-5x better than YouTube
- It's the only audience you truly control
Start today:
- Choose an email platform (ConvertKit or Mailchimp)
- Create a simple lead magnet
- Add signup link to your next video
- Send your first newsletter this week
Don't wait until you lose your YouTube channel to wish you had started building your list earlier.
Start now while you still have reach.
Next Steps
- Try Riffit Free - Convert your videos to newsletters in 30 seconds
- Download Newsletter Templates - Free templates to get started
- See Examples - Real newsletter examples from creators
Last updated: March 10, 2024
Ready to Convert Your YouTube Videos?
Try Riffit free for 3 conversions. No credit card required.
Start Converting - It's FreeShare this article: