Best Newsletter Formats for YouTube Content Creators in 2024

You've decided to convert your YouTube videos to newsletters (smart move!). But which format should you use?

The format you choose dramatically impacts open rates, engagement, and whether people actually read your emails. Choose wrong, and you're wasting time. Choose right, and you build a highly engaged email list.

After analyzing 500+ newsletter campaigns from YouTube creators, we've identified the three formats that work best—and more importantly, when to use each one.

The 3 Newsletter Formats That Work

Format 1: Deep Dive (1000-1500 words)

Best for: Tutorials, educational content, course-style videos

Structure:

• Comprehensive introduction with context
• Step-by-step walkthrough with details
• Code snippets, screenshots, or detailed examples
• Common mistakes section
• Resource list and next steps

Why it works: Your audience chose to learn something complex. They want depth, not surface-level takeaways. The Deep Dive format delivers complete value in written form.

Real example: A coding tutorial YouTube video (45 minutes) converted to a Deep Dive newsletter achieved:

• 32% open rate
• 8.5 minute average reading time
• 12% click-through to video for visual demos
• 6% reply rate with specific questions

When to use:

• How-to tutorials
• Technical content
• Course lessons
• Detailed explanations
• Multi-step processes

---

Format 2: Quick Read (500-750 words)

Best for: Interviews, talks, podcast episodes, news commentary

Structure:

• TL;DR summary at the very top
• 3-5 key insights with brief context
• Quotable moments (pull quotes)
• Quick action items or takeaways
• Prominent link to full video

Why it works: Not every email needs to be long. Quick Read respects your reader's time while delivering immediate value. Perfect for busy professionals who scan emails.

Real example: A 60-minute expert interview converted to Quick Read format achieved:

• 38% open rate (higher than Deep Dive!)
• 3.5 minute average reading time
• 15% click-through to watch full interview
• High forward rate (people shared it)

When to use:

• Guest interviews
• Conference talks
• Podcast episodes
• Panel discussions
• News/commentary videos

---

Format 3: Actionable (600-900 words)

Best for: Strategy videos, frameworks, tips, how-to content

Structure:

• Clear outcome stated upfront
• Numbered action steps (very specific)
• Checklist format for easy scanning
• Tools and resources mentioned
• Concrete next steps

Why it works: People love actionable content they can implement immediately. The checklist format makes it easy to scan, save, and reference later.

Real example: A strategy video on "SEO for YouTube" converted to Actionable format achieved:

• 35% open rate
• 5.2 minute average reading time
• 22% click-through to video
• 18% saved to folder (high reference value)

When to use:

• Strategy breakdowns
• Step-by-step frameworks
• Tips and tactics
• Checklists
• Implementation guides

---

Format Comparison Table

| Format | Length | Read Time | Best For | Avg Open Rate | Avg CTR | |--------|--------|-----------|----------|---------------|---------| | Deep Dive | 1000-1500 words | 8-10 min | Tutorials, education | 28-32% | 8-12% | | Quick Read | 500-750 words | 3-5 min | Interviews, talks | 35-40% | 12-18% | | Actionable | 600-900 words | 5-7 min | Strategy, frameworks | 32-36% | 18-25% |

---

How to Choose the Right Format

Ask yourself these questions:

1. What's the video's primary goal?

• Teach a skill → Deep Dive
• Share insights → Quick Read
• Provide a framework → Actionable

2. What's your audience's intent?

• Learn deeply → Deep Dive
• Stay informed → Quick Read
• Implement quickly → Actionable

3. How complex is the content?

• Requires depth → Deep Dive
• High-level overview → Quick Read
• Step-by-step process → Actionable

4. What's your content production capacity?

• One video/week → Any format
• Daily content → Quick Read
• Monthly deep content → Deep Dive

---

Real Examples: Same Video, Different Formats

Let's see how the same video would work in each format.

Original Video: "How I Grew My YouTube Channel to 100K Subscribers in 6 Months"

As Deep Dive:

Subject: How I Grew to 100K Subscribers: Complete Timeline & Strategy

Introduction: The full story (200 words)
Month 1: Getting Started (200 words)
Month 2-3: Finding My Niche (250 words)
Month 4-5: Scaling Content (250 words)
Month 6: Hitting 100K (200 words)
Resources & Tools Used (150 words)

Total: ~1200 words

As Quick Read:

Subject: 5 Lessons From Growing to 100K Subscribers in 6 Months

TL;DR: Hit 100K in 6 months using these 5 strategies

1. Niche Selection: Why I picked [topic] (80 words)
2. Upload Schedule: Consistency beats perfection (70 words)
3. Thumbnails: The 3-second test (70 words)
4. Titles: My exact formula (80 words)
5. Community: Reply to every comment (70 words)

Watch the full story: [link]

Total: ~600 words

As Actionable:

Subject: Your 6-Month Plan to 100K YouTube Subscribers

Here's the exact plan that took me from 0 to 100K:

Month 1:
☐ Pick your niche (specific criteria)
☐ Create channel assets
☐ Publish first 3 videos

Month 2:
☐ Analyze which video performed best
☐ Double down on that topic
☐ Start email list

[... continues for 6 months]

Tools you'll need:
- TubeBuddy for keyword research
- Canva for thumbnails
- Riffit for newsletters

Total: ~750 words

---

Mixing Formats: The Pro Strategy

Don't feel locked into one format. The best creators use all three strategically:

Weekly schedule example:

• Monday: Deep Dive tutorial (main video of the week)
• Wednesday: Quick Read (interview or news commentary)
• Friday: Actionable (weekly tips or framework)

Monthly schedule example:

• Week 1: Deep Dive (comprehensive guide)
• Week 2: Quick Read (quick wins)
• Week 3: Actionable (step-by-step implementation)
• Week 4: Deep Dive (case study)

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake #1: Using Deep Dive for Everything

Why it's wrong: Not every video deserves 1500 words. Respect your readers' time.

Fix: Match format to content type. Interviews → Quick Read. Tutorials → Deep Dive.

Mistake #2: Making Quick Reads TOO Short

Why it's wrong: "Watch the video" with 100 words isn't a newsletter—it's clickbait.

Fix: Provide 70% of value in email, save 30% for video. Quick Read should still be valuable standalone.

Mistake #3: Actionable Without Specific Steps

Why it's wrong: Vague advice like "optimize your videos" isn't actionable.

Fix: Be specific. "Use TubeBuddy to find keywords with 1K-10K monthly searches and low competition."

---

Subject Lines for Each Format

Deep Dive Subject Lines:

• ✅ "Complete Guide: [Topic] for Beginners"
• ✅ "How to [Achieve Result]: Step-by-Step Tutorial"
• ✅ "Deep Dive: [Topic] - Everything You Need to Know"

Quick Read Subject Lines:

• ✅ "5 Lessons From [Experience/Result]"
• ✅ "What I Learned From [Guest Name] About [Topic]"
• ✅ "Key Takeaways: [Video Title]"

Actionable Subject Lines:

• ✅ "Your [Timeframe] Action Plan for [Result]"
• ✅ "Checklist: [How to Achieve X]"
• ✅ "[Number]-Step Framework for [Desired Outcome]"

---

Testing and Optimization

Don't guess—test these formats with your audience:

Week 1-2: Test Deep Dive

• Send 2 Deep Dive newsletters
• Track open rate, read time, CTR

Week 3-4: Test Quick Read

• Send 2 Quick Read newsletters
• Compare metrics to Deep Dive

Week 5-6: Test Actionable

• Send 2 Actionable newsletters
• Identify which format resonates most

Week 7+: Optimize

• Use your winner as primary format
• Mix in other formats occasionally
• Continue tracking and iterating

---

Tools to Speed This Up

Manual Approach:

• Extract YouTube transcript
• Reformat based on chosen template
• ~2-3 hours per newsletter

AI-Powered Approach (Riffit):

• Paste video URL
• Select format (Deep Dive / Quick Read / Actionable)
• Get formatted newsletter in 30 seconds

---

Conclusion

There's no "best" newsletter format—only the best format for your specific content and audience.

Quick decision guide:

• Teaching something complex? → Deep Dive
• Sharing insights or interviews? → Quick Read
• Providing a framework or strategy? → Actionable

Start with one format that matches your content style, test it for 4 weeks, then experiment with others.

The format matters less than consistency. Pick one and publish weekly.

Your next step: Take your most recent YouTube video and convert it using the format that best matches its content type.

---

Resources

• Convert Your First Video Free
• See Real Examples
• Download Newsletter Templates

---

Last updated: March 12, 2024